This is a MUSIC forum. Irrelevant or disrespectful posts/topics will be removed by Admin. Please report any forum spam or inappropriate posts HERE.

All users can post to this forum on general music topics.

Moderators: bandmixmod1, jimmy990, spikedace

#197951 by fisherman bob
Sat Dec 15, 2012 3:07 am
I can see the British influence thing. I would completely get rid of the harmonies and just have ONE voice, whether it's yours (and I've heard famous voices that are way more turdish than yours) or somebody else you prefer. Being out of phase makes it difficult to understand the lyrics, and if there's one thing I hate it's incomprehensible lyrics. I like the song, yeah it's quirky perhaps, but it's interesting, and it's got a lot of possibilities with cleaning up the vocals.

#197960 by Starfish Scott
Sat Dec 15, 2012 4:14 am
Oh you people are on crack...yea this is the wrestling match right here. lol

Evidently he thinks like you do Bob and I VEHEMENTLY disagree.

The harmonic version is the only thing I like, else it's MONOTONE>!.
(and no bueno)

You got something against creative license or why can't I have my weird harmonic?

People that say that gall me. Go back to the 50's.

I am treading water in that clean environment from the get go, considering that "Bridgette" is more my style/sound.

AS for those vocals, WE spent 8 hours cleaning it up and redoing the balance in the vocals so that the harmony part(s) was equal to the rest.

As I said it was done, Monday night. Suddenly it's a week later and I get what seems to be the same version pre Monday's 8 hour adjustment.

I check my email to see if it could be a version mistake, no.

I think it was a "command decision", except someone else is in charge of my regiment and we know that is not the protocol. lol

This tune was discussed. I said that "I thought the low part was not enough to sustain the tune". We worked with it and it was improved enough that I was ready to "show the dog".

Next thing you know..

#197961 by Starfish Scott
Sat Dec 15, 2012 4:15 am
Jahva wrote:I don't know what it would sound like with the vocal blend you wanted but I don't think this version works.
The loss of the harmony takes away the feeling of melody with just the one low voice. imo. Makes it more monotone. Harmonies create depth and accents. You can decipher it in a few spots but... sounds like you expected more balance.
Everything else is fine as for performance instrument mix tech stuff. Over-all the quality sounded good in me headphones.
But it also sounds like it's been a struggle to get it this far...
:?


This is more or less exactly how I feel.

Removing the harmony was like "gutting a starfish".
You f**k up my tune and out you go like "old coffee grounds and fish heads".

very-very upset.

Someone just blew the "come back and kick me whistle". - Stewie

:shock: :shock: :shock: :shock:

#197968 by lalong
Sat Dec 15, 2012 5:45 am
First of all Scott you can drop the innuendo. I think most people are smart enough to figure out who I am. Really, you couldn’t just say: “I don’t like it please pull it?” Nope man it’s always something personal, always some big drama.

Of course you will never hear me bitch at you, about my playing. I don’t give a rat’s ass how you mix it. It’s not perfect, but I have no problems standing by what I do. If the quality of the performance is directly dependant upon how much can be thrown at it afterwards, then it was lacking to begin with. It happens, get over yourself. Or just blame me, cool whatever gets you by.

No good deed goes unpunished. It’s my equipment we are using, it’s my time I’m spending, regardless of YOUR convenience it happens on MY schedule. So if it took a week to do, you are welcome. Your arrogance to actually bitch about how long anything I have done takes, is beyond astounding.

It’s my effort that gets every single song finished. If it doesn’t come out to your expectations I hardly need, or deserve some ignorant emotional crucifixion in my email. It’s unprofessional and doesn’t even make sense, as if I would sabotage my own work as well. Yet another huge blowup over something as trivial as a poor mix that we could have simply fixed, but it’s much more important to burn my good will instead. Working with you isn’t merely hard, it’s impossible.

I think it’s an excellent idea that we go our separate ways man. If either of us have a future at all in music, it’s certainly not together.

You have a copy of every song we did right? I want to know because I’ll be deleting our profiles on Soundclick and Reverbnation. It’s not out of spite, I just don’t want any association with yourself and any future derived from those efforts would be tenuous at best. I’m saying it here because I want it known as public record. Three months later I don’t to read about how I’m trying to screw you over by deleting our crap. So download them now, or not, they will be gone next Friday. Do your own profiles and put them up there, or whatever, I don’t care. It’s been fun man, good luck.
Last edited by lalong on Sat Dec 15, 2012 6:07 am, edited 2 times in total.

#197969 by fisherman bob
Sat Dec 15, 2012 5:54 am
Did I mention something about self publishing?

#197971 by gtZip
Sat Dec 15, 2012 6:29 am
lalong wrote:First of all Scott you can drop the innuendo. I think most people are smart enough to figure out who I am. Really, you couldn’t just say: “I don’t like it please pull it?” Nope man it’s always something personal, always some big drama.

Of course you will never hear me bitch at you, about my playing. I don’t give a rat’s ass how you mix it. It’s not perfect, but I have no problems standing by what I do. If the quality of the performance is directly dependant upon how much can be thrown at it afterwards, then it was lacking to begin with. It happens, get over yourself. Or just blame me, cool whatever gets you by.

No good deed goes unpunished. It’s my equipment we are using, it’s my time I’m spending, regardless of YOUR convenience it happens on MY schedule. So if it took a week to do, you are welcome. Your arrogance to actually bitch about how long anything I have done takes, is beyond astounding.

It’s my effort that gets every single song finished. If it doesn’t come out to your expectations I hardly need, or deserve some ignorant emotional crucifixion in my email. It’s unprofessional and doesn’t even make sense, as if I would sabotage my own work as well. Yet another huge blowup over something as trivial as a poor mix that we could have simply fixed, but it’s much more important to burn my good will instead. Working with you isn’t merely hard, it’s impossible.

I think it’s an excellent idea that we go our separate ways man. If either of us have a future at all in music, it’s certainly not together.

You have a copy of every song we did right? I want to know because I’ll be deleting our profiles on Soundclick and Reverbnation. It’s not out of spite, I just don’t want any association with yourself and any future derived from those efforts would be tenuous at best. I’m saying it here because I want it known as public record. Three months later I don’t to read about how I’m trying to screw you over by deleting our crap. So download them now, or not, they will be gone next Friday. Do your own profiles and put them up there, or whatever, I don’t care. It’s been fun man, good luck.


You could simply fix the mix - except you didn't.
All of that "my equipment, my time" junk - I've seen that before...
That's why I say "do it yourself", or pay a studio.

#197976 by PaperDog
Sat Dec 15, 2012 7:20 am
lalong wrote:First of all Scott you can drop the innuendo. I think most people are smart enough to figure out who I am. Really, you couldn’t just say: “I don’t like it please pull it?” Nope man it’s always something personal, always some big drama.

Of course you will never hear me bitch at you, about my playing. I don’t give a rat’s ass how you mix it. It’s not perfect, but I have no problems standing by what I do. If the quality of the performance is directly dependant upon how much can be thrown at it afterwards, then it was lacking to begin with. It happens, get over yourself. Or just blame me, cool whatever gets you by.

No good deed goes unpunished. It’s my equipment we are using, it’s my time I’m spending, regardless of YOUR convenience it happens on MY schedule. So if it took a week to do, you are welcome. Your arrogance to actually bitch about how long anything I have done takes, is beyond astounding.

It’s my effort that gets every single song finished. If it doesn’t come out to your expectations I hardly need, or deserve some ignorant emotional crucifixion in my email. It’s unprofessional and doesn’t even make sense, as if I would sabotage my own work as well. Yet another huge blowup over something as trivial as a poor mix that we could have simply fixed, but it’s much more important to burn my good will instead. Working with you isn’t merely hard, it’s impossible.

I think it’s an excellent idea that we go our separate ways man. If either of us have a future at all in music, it’s certainly not together.

You have a copy of every song we did right? I want to know because I’ll be deleting our profiles on Soundclick and Reverbnation. It’s not out of spite, I just don’t want any association with yourself and any future derived from those efforts would be tenuous at best. I’m saying it here because I want it known as public record. Three months later I don’t to read about how I’m trying to screw you over by deleting our crap. So download them now, or not, they will be gone next Friday. Do your own profiles and put them up there, or whatever, I don’t care. It’s been fun man, good luck.


Yikes, You guys ... need to kiss an make up... You have been great partners and you've cranked out some great material together. Scotty is having one of his panic attacks... Surely you both are on to that by now... Its what makes Scotty...Scotty... (Ever seen an African wild dog when its cornered? LOL!) And You, Lalong, Its very obvious that you put in the time , heart and spirit (I hear it on so many of the tracks you guys post).

I think you guys should just tough it out, get past it and work together more. But it might help to take a break form it for a few weeks... Curb the urge and spend time with your families instead...

In The meantime, can somebody throw a Snickers candy bar to Scotty? LOl!
:wink: :D 8)

#197986 by GuitarMikeB
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:44 pm
Lalong - there is potential in that song, but if you read the comments here, it needs work.

Maybe you and Scott can no longer function as a team/partners - it happens. But partners are supposed to work together, from his comments you wouldn't listen to what he was suggesting be done with the song. When it's one person making all the decisions, then its no longer a partnership.
'Taking all your partnered songs off line' - you're acting like a spoiled kid now. Grow a thicker skin, or get out of the music business. Decide if you want to do stuff totally on your own (and not listen to others' opinions and suggestions) or work with others to improve your songs and abilities.

#197989 by Starfish Scott
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:56 pm
No f**k this, it wasn't a guess that it should have been a "harmony", gimme a faqing break you moron(s).

With one simple misstep you screwed the pooch so well it's astounding.

It was panic attack but not by me, plain and simple and instead of doing what we agree on, you think you got the lay of the land.
(Sorry, you just won the goat, not what's behind curtain #1).

When we say it's done, that means hands off. No more bullshit and tweaking for 70+ hours. You're so insecure you just can't stop yourself.

I knew what it's supposed to sound like, but you sure didn't.

"Take that noise down and dump it like the crap it is" I could give a fat crap at this point...

To finish it off, my Jeep got hit badly last night by a hit and run driver.
(But I get the drift, Dec 2012, it has a life all it's own.)

You proved where you are at to me and there's no going back.

The only tool you need to finish a mix is "a giant spoon" you "cake maker".. LOL

You go on and do what you do, just find a reasonable victim that is dumb enough to let you do it cause that sure as hell isn't me.

Don't discourage him from taking that nonsense down. I think he's right, for once.

To be fair to him, he does a great job playing keys and mixing/mastering usually.
This just wasn't one of those times and to consider that this was all "fixed" and done on Monday, only to have to endure missing "my ride" by a week and to have this basically sabotaged, is too much for me.

Write with someone else, you mellon smasher.

You remind me of "Gallagher at a farmer's market".

You wanna talk? Ok, let's talk about how Chippy offered to play with us and you never even told me.
Careful Chippy is around for comment !!!! That might not go your way but I am sure as hell inclined to hear what he thinks.

He even put up a comment on ReverbNation, but the "controller" didn't like that. Nope, thus no comment and no mention. (buried)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controller ... _Comics%29

I should just call you "Basil Sandhurst".

:shock:

Don't get me going because next will be about how you didn't accept people that wanted to be "fans" because they were playing the wrong genre.

(It's a numbers game and the devil could ask to be a fan, we wouldn't turn him away either, well unless you were at the helm.)

Oh Chippy? Where are ya man, come clear some of this up for better or for worse. He knows some of this story as well.

I'm sure he's got something to say..wonder if you'll like that?
My guess is that it will be a resounding "no", but if he feels that I am wrong, I'll take it on the chin like an adult. Bring me the judge..he's qualified to rule on this.


Why don't you go ask someone who has no clue? I bet there are a few hanging around that qualify yet..ya giant fumbler with the ear of tin.

ech..ya make my stomach hurt ...better to have it implode now than in 5 tunes.

We could have yet another tune I really like get all mangled up because you popped your brain out of joint and decided to change the mix without actually telling anyone and then posting it to the internet on the sites that actually matter or you could just neglect to mix it correctly like "Invisible light".

See the tunes he doesn't like, he doesn't fully mix. It's like hedging your bet, only this one wasn't improperly mixed, it was flat out screwed in the a$$.

Maybe that actually needed to be said for once, because it's been echoing around for a while now.

"If you could do it by yourself, you wouldn't need me".
Just like, "if I could master/mix as well as you I would relegate you to playing keys only and you'd never get to touch a mix again".
You aren't in touch enough to make that decision alone, jerkoff and worse, we had this discussion. You just thought you'd slip that one by..

Noooooooooooo (waives big finger) Buh-bye now..

#197993 by KLUGMO
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:23 pm
I just dont understand people sometimes.

Why would you post a song here for critique that in YOUR OWN opinion
is a TURD.[/b]

#197995 by Starfish Scott
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:36 pm
I didn't post it on Soundclick and on Reverbnation, he did.

He knows what's good. (cough) bullshit (cough)

And Paperdog, "what do they think they are hand models"? lol
That's for you..and I am no Joe Pesci, thank god.

No, we had this conversation and Les decided that this was the best way to go. (?????????) The next thing I know, it's on the sites.

The version I heard on Monday wasn't like this, but a sharp knife will do this to your work at the hands of a sleep deprived dude.

And it's up to #13. "Jesus help me". The irony has got me stunned.

Gee if I wonder if I'll get a call from Lance's Producer friend?
And then what do I tell him?

"Ah sorry about the Harmony, Les decided he wanted it that way... the end". "Ah no he didn't tell me, he just did it because he thought the monotone thing was better".. lol

(SPINS cylinder and holds gun to own head and peeks to see if the bullet is lined up, CLICK)(Nope, not that time.)(SPINS AGAIN)(click)

#198001 by PaperDog
Sat Dec 15, 2012 4:22 pm
Chief Engineer Scott wrote:And Paperdog, "what do they think they are hand models"? lol
That's for you..and I am no Joe Pesci, thank god.


Good One ! Ha ha!

Seriously , you guys... I think KLugmo has a point ... Somebody pulled a coitus interuptus on the creation of that baby... Too soon to post.

I can tell you in my own experience, george dumped a few tracks that I wasnt quite ready to let go... The guitar work on No Loss of will...Kinda took some dive there and we redid it...its just not the same... Happens all the time I think with music creation.
But to be fair, I dont think I could ever be both a musician AND and engineer. Its daunting... and communication is destined for entanglement.

We'd never heard of this song you released, and so we wouldnt really have known that a harmony was missing or the mix was different before hand.

Like I said, you guys have done great things together, and should just chill before you throw it all away.

BTW, I'm working on an R&B (almost a tinge of Jazz) song now called "Find A Way"

"...Before you walk away
before you say its over...
Before we kill the day
Let's think it over...

... Before you move ahead,
and you look away...
Remember what we said...
We'd find a way....


Its fitting for you two...Work it out dudes... SOme day in the future you will laugh your asses off about it over some kick- ass Blue Moon Winter Ale...

#198003 by fisherman bob
Sat Dec 15, 2012 5:42 pm
Is it possible to take this to another studio at this time?

#198006 by Sir Jamsalot
Sat Dec 15, 2012 7:14 pm
KLUGMO wrote:I just dont understand people sometimes.

Why would you post a song here for critique that in YOUR OWN opinion
is a TURD.[/b]


LOL. This whole thread is drama.

Chief: "Hey everyone, look at this and tell me what you think!"
BMIX: "I give it a 3/5"
Chief: "Damn - I knew it was crap! Hey everyone, it's crap! I blame the mixer!"
Mixer: "STFU, bbye!"
Chief: "oh yeah? well, don't come back! and Chippy! shut up before you come here and start yackin!"

lovely

#198007 by PaperDog
Sat Dec 15, 2012 7:20 pm
Red Tuesday wrote:
KLUGMO wrote:I just dont understand people sometimes.

Why would you post a song here for critique that in YOUR OWN opinion
is a TURD.[/b]


LOL. This whole thread is drama.

Chief: "Hey everyone, look at this and tell me what you think!"
BMIX: "I give it a 3/5"
Chief: "Damn - I knew it was crap! Hey everyone, it's crap! I blame the mixer!"
Mixer: "STFU, bbye!"
Chief: "oh yeah? well, don't come back! and Chippy! shut up before you come here and start yackin!"

lovely


Hey this coulfd be a song!

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest