RhythmMan sorry that this is a bit of a duplication of your earlier thread about the alleged music found in DaVinci's painting "The Last Supper" but I couldn't find it so I posted this...
Anyway I played the music line as best I could read it, and posted the clip on my profile (it's marked "Hidden DaVinci Music?"). Personally, I don't hear anything in it. I think the author of that book sort of contrived something out of nothing there. Not only is it not really musically compelling, but notice most of the notes are the first staff "E" only because so many of the apostles' hands are simply resting on a common plane - the table.
Am I wrong? Does anyone hear something in this or read the notes differently that would make melodic/tonic sense?
Anyway I played the music line as best I could read it, and posted the clip on my profile (it's marked "Hidden DaVinci Music?"). Personally, I don't hear anything in it. I think the author of that book sort of contrived something out of nothing there. Not only is it not really musically compelling, but notice most of the notes are the first staff "E" only because so many of the apostles' hands are simply resting on a common plane - the table.
Am I wrong? Does anyone hear something in this or read the notes differently that would make melodic/tonic sense?