joseph6 wrote:My opinion...HACK. MTV created Nirvana. Maybe I just don't get it, though.
I "get it" - but I still don't think he's a genius.
I mean, it's really simple - Cobain came along and wrote something different - something that resonated with a generation of angst-ridden teenagers.
The 80's was about hair metal - sex, drugs and rock and roll. The 90's rolled out and there were a whole generation of kids growing up who simply couldn't relate to sex, drugs and rock and roll. Their parents were hippies to put the clamps down because of their own wild youth. So you had a generation of kids being raised in these sheltered environments. They needed an outlet. Cobain's lyrics spoke to them. It reflected how they felt.
So, it makes sense in that context. When music speaks to you, it speaks to you.
But I don't think that makes him a genius just because he tapped into that.
I love a lot of music - my tastes range from Natalie Imbruglia and Stars to Alter Bridge and Dream Theater. But just because a song speaks to me doesn't mean I automatically label the artist "genius". It just happens to be a song that reaches me...
I think Cobain, like so many people before him, was the right guy at the right time. And that's a factor of luck, in a way.
I think you could call him a lyrical genius IF his music would reach people for generations to come. But his lyrics were specific to a group of people at a particular time in history. I don't think they resonate now.
But when I listen to John Lennon's "Imagine"... that resonates forever. Now that is musical genius, to me at least.