SDavis22 wrote:Then you've been a fan prior to our exchange?
There's that tasteless self-flattery being used as a meaningless, sarcastic tool I was referring to. lol. If by "fan" you mean a reader of posts as I've done with many other users on this forum, then yes, I'm just as much a fan of you as I am everybody else. lol.
Like you, I've been exposed to a lot of music - willingly and unwillingly. Unwillingly only when a friend plays something that doesn't particularly appeal to me or if it's something I can see through.
Perhaps I have gained my tolerance for music via similar scenarios. Thanks to my wonderful girlfriend, I'm gaining a hearty exposure to country. It's been difficult but I'm finally coming around to a lot of it. I will say that if there is any genre I just can't stand a majority of these days, it's hip-hop. I understand why the music makes people want to shake their butts, lol, but it's the lyrics and talentless talking into the mic for singing that really urks me the most. This isn't for all hip-hop bands, though. Clearly, my opinion as such places me in a minority as these rappers are making an amount equal to that which I will probably never see a fraction of in my entire life but that's alright. Anyway, apologies for the short rant.
Uematsu does do film and video game soundtracks doesn't he? How does that show that I'm stuck in a 'Rock and Roll' box.
While his career has been shaped with his works for video games, his solo endeavors, such as the album 'Phantasmagora', are rich with musical genius. You may laugh at "video game music" but outside of the context of video games, the music he created for the later Final Fantasy series is absolutely incredible. The fact that he landed such a job is just icing on the cake for the man. To laughably shrug him off as solely a "video game musician" is why I said you're stuck. No, you're not truly "stuck," I was merely exaggerating a point.
We both know that our influences don't show all that we listen to so neither of us truly knows the extent of the other's musical taste.
Then why make the comment you made regarding this?
Even though it means nothing, my small list of 'influences' cover more genres than your list...
Let's compare, shall we?
Music as a whole influences me.A genreless generalization of music, thus encompassing all genres. I've got you beat right there. lol. Only kidding.

I find myself wishing I could do everything from write with Seal or Sting to write polymetric material like Textures or Meshuggah. I find inspiration from all ends of the musical spectrum. (It's worth mentioning that there is plenty of terrible music out there as well that influences me to NOT want to sound like it, lol) In no particular order and certainly nowhere near the full extent of my influeces:I wrote this to sum up and at least tweak the interest of those like you who would possibly question my musical exposure and full range of influence. While I listed my immediate influences (which isn't even half of who immediately influences me these days), I more than expressed my inclination to be influenced by much more than what you see. From there, people could either assume and walk along, as it seems you would have, or they could approach me and ask, which seems to be something you're fond of pointing out.
Code: Select all
TesseracT: Polymetric Ambient Metal
The Chronicles of Israfel (Dominic Cifarelli): Ambient experimental progressive rock
Textures: Polymetric Metal
Seal: Pop and New Age
Yanni: New Age
Sting: New Age, Pop and Classic Rock (The Police included when I say Sting but I know that isn't obvious.)
Steve Vai: Instrumental Rock
Bumblefoot: Instrumental Rock, Rock, Pop, Jazz, Funk, Blues, Chicken Pickin'
Fabrizio Leo: Jazz, Fusion, Blues, Instrumental Rock
Scott Mishoe: Instrumental Fusion, Funk
DJ Noumenon: Hip-hop DJ with very relaxing tracks.
Meshuggah: Polymetric Metal
POD: Hard Rock
Ra: Hard Rock and Hard Rock Ballads
Nobuo Uematsu: Classical, New Age
Periphery (Bulb): Polymetric Ambient Metal
Symphony X: Progressive Rock/Neoclassical
Dream Theater: Progressive Hard Rock
Rush: Classic Progressive Rock
...all musicians who are proficient with their instrument - regardless of what instrument they play,Speaks for itself and covers every genre. I literally meant that.
Code: Select all
Sikth: Polymetric Metal
Ankla: Metalcore
Puya: Hard Rock fused with Latin elements.
Dark New Day: Hard Rock
Sevendust (before Clint left to form DND): Hard Rock
Divine Heresy: Heavy Metal
Silverchair (Daniel Johns is a genius): Rock, Hard Rock, Pop, Dramatic (Broadway-type of songs in albums such as Diorama)
the list just goes on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and you get the picture...Simply a reiteration of all of the aforementioned.
As for you, well, you covered many genres and gave specific examples of each. You listed early folk music, early blues, R&B, country, jazz, rock, motown, soul, funk, and R&B from the '60s.
I do believe you are correct in saying you listed more genres than me but my reiterations were meant to allude to (not specify) much more. I really am looking forward to what it is you've written. My assumption (bear with me here) is that you will sound nothing like 90% of your influences. Nice list, though, as I stated previously and I do enjoy at least some of the music of every single artist you've listed there sans Carter Family and Maddox Brothers of whom I don't recall hearing but may have, just unknowingly as to who I was hearing.
The whole 'doom, apocalyptic, gloomy, angry, satan, death' Metal pretense is quite cliche in my mind - but that's my opinion. I like some heavy music but in the long run it's just not that important to me - I find a lot of it to be too pretentious. And calling some of what you like 'good' is up for debate... it's all relative to personal taste. Yes, you'll just have to trust that I'm open minded...
I'll take gloomy and angry as they can be found in just about every genre but everything else is a 90's metal state of mind. Doom, apocalypse, satan and death... meh, I tend to ignore the lyrics when it comes to such cliches. I will give you those but they are simply commonplace and a staple for their specific place within the metal spectrum. I may be really into metal but certainly not all of it. I can't stand black metal and a majority of death metal. Oh, and power rock annoys me these days, too... Sonata Arctica, Dragonforce, etc. Talented musicians but boring music.
I'm not yet up for debating why you think a lot of what I listen to is sub-par and I don't. You're absolutely right that it's all relative to personal taste, so for the time being, let's just leave it at we like who we like. I AM up for debating the issue, just not in this thread. Rain check?
This last reply of yours allows me to see you for being a little more open-minded than I had originally thought. +1, Seth.
Like I said, my list of influences covers more ground then yours does. I never listed my influences but I suppose you could have looked them up and somehow concluded that I'm not well rounded. Your very last sentence above can be said about me as well - we're the same here. I could go into why I don't enjoy many of the artists you listed if you'd like me to. Throughout the history of music there have been so many great artists, creations, innovations; Heavy music just seems entirely insignificant to me - again, I could go into why if you'd like.
See reply above regarding list of influences. I'm curious as to what you mean by you never listed your influences. I got them from your bandmix profile. You certainly seem well-rounded with what you like but you didn't even allude to anything other than the genres you specified. It seems as though my listing the likes of Muddy Waters and B.B. King would be equal to that of you listing early Silverchair or Rush. If someone wants to know, we'll tell them, otherwise, it's moot to bash one another for not listing everything we enjoy.
Why would you claim to be well rounded and post such a vague list? If you were trying to prove something then you should have listed more bands and genres for me to sift through. I'm not assuming, I'm concluding based on what you've given me (sound familiar?). If it's important enough for you to prove otherwise then I'll be looking forward to it. What other assumptions have I made? I've got time; I'm taking online classes so I'm here for hours...
Once again, you missed my point. My claim of well-roundedness was to be fully supported by solely my bandmix list of influences. I've just been using that which I've mentioned and written here on bandmix, as have you. What you consider vague was merely an effort to allow an avenue for those interested to inquire on what more they'd like to know that wasn't listed. That's all. If you wanted more bands to sift through, all you had to do before was ask. I won't sit here and attempt to prove my well-roundedness right now - I have a feeling we'll both demonstrate our well-roundedness in the end. I will just trust you for now.
phrailguitarist wrote:Quote:
- but, different strokes I guess...
Uh oh... Is that what I think it is?
An aphorism?
Clever twist but you're not getting away with it that easily, Seth. lol.
I didn't assume your influences aren't well rounded, all one has to do is look. And nobody's perfect... we all know that. And by all means, listen to my song when I post it. I'll listen to your music as well - when I'm not sitting here with a throbbing headache.
Agreed. I would like to think you'll be pleasantly surprised by what you hear. If you listen to my songs with a critique on songwriting and production, you'll be disappointed. What I posted was merely to showcase a few of my ideas as a guitarist to tweak the interest of potential musicians I'd like to work with. Unlike MacLeod, I rather enjoy a lot of what I write regardless of negative opinion from others. Constructive criticism is one thing but just as everyone likes music, they also like to hate music. Take what I have posted on my player for what it's worth and if you don't have anything good or positively (not sarcastically) constructive to say, then please refrain from commenting and I'll do the same with yours.
A reiteration without my having to type it:phrailguitarist wrote:I acknowledge your intelligence and feel that your opinion could be beneficial on any given topic. Don't let that go to your head, though. Self-flattery is incredibly tasteless - even when used solely as a meaningless sarcastic tool.
Well said.
You know neither of us would return and waste the time if it were completely fruitless...
Good call. Agreed.
You'll agree that blasphemy from a nonbeliever is less severe than from a believer. Perhaps you didn't find my preface as humorous or ironic as I did.
I actually thought I found your preface to be more ironic and humorous than you, seeing it as without being face-to-face with you and getting a feel for your sarcasm, it appeared as if you were just making your closing remarks. And yes, I will agree. 110%.
-Stephen