Shredd6 wrote:Mikey,
first and foremost: you are clearly going out of your way to disrespect me by giving me a name that suggest you are talking down to me, or that I am your jr/pet... and it seems like the last resort of a desperate debater.
While I, on the other hand, am a master (de) bater (hehe). Laugh for a minute... don't take things too seriously, but do give me the respect I deserve.
Shredd6 wrote:For one thing, you're adding your own time-frames to things. Show me where I mentioned a matter of 6-months. That's what I consider spinning.
admittedly you never mentioned 6 months. I grabbed that out of the air arbitrarily. 6 months, a year, 2 years: has no impact on the point.
Shredd6 wrote:Cheap labor had taken over the cabinet business here years ago.
let me make this clear: my argument is only that it is not the 'illegal/legal-immigrants' that are the problem, and that you/i/we are bigots for cursing them for what we ourselves would do if in their shoes. We are so easily convinced when the govt' tells us it's their fault that we never even consider that it's our fault. They may, in fact manifest as a symptom of the problem, but they ARE NOT the problem. It is the fact that fewer and fewer things are being produced in the usa because everyone here just wants the 'best deal'. We don't 'buy american' and that is why GM is going down. We outsource while we enjoy a std of living that is more and more beyond our means.
Shredd6 wrote:After a mold is made of an architectural part, it is sent over to have the part made of concrete. In the company I worked for at the time, the whole concrete department was employed by illegal immigrants. The crew was about I would say 50--60 illegal workers in the department.
We were building the whole outside facade of the Venetian hotel....
interesting story, but it doesn't make the point that immigrants are to blame for our problems because that company should have lost their license over it long before it became effected many americans. Again, the illegals/legals aren't the prob... perhaps its the biz that the prob, perhaps it's the fundamental flaw of capitalism that eventually you run out of markets/cheap-labor to exploit... but it is anything but the immigrants fault and I tried to explain that to you with an analogy where we annex mexico and eventually the wage gets back up there and we outsource... putting us right back were we started but w/o the immigrant to blame.
Shredd6 wrote:I just don't think you understand how big of a problem it can be Mikey. Once a group of illegal immigrants make up a big portion of a company, they have a way of holding the company hostage, and finding ways to keep American workers out of the picture. The only way they can keep that stronghold, is to work for cheap wages, and band together as a unit..
-you use this analogy to draw the conclusion that 'this is why we should keep them out'... I use it to draw the conclusion that even if you 'keep them out', your job will be outsourced.
Shredd6 wrote:You can't justify any of it by saying, 'well if it was that easy of a job to do, then you deserve to have the job taken from you" or " If it's that easy than you deserve to be denied the right to work" or "they're doing work Americans don't want to do".
ok, get your tape recorder out: I was wrong to say I don't care if they take unskilled labor away from americans. What I should have said is that ultimately, this is not the problem... so I am not concerned with it.
Shredd6 wrote:A legal American worker in the US has every right above ANY illegal worker no matter how "easy" the job may seem to be. And at this stage of the economy, I know of a huge amount of American people from the 18-25 range who are dying to find ANY job no matter if it's minimum wage or not.. I personally know of many kids in the 18-20 range who haven't been able to work their FIRST job yet. A lot of the construction jobs around here are being eaten alive by illegal workers who may have years of experience in their craft and are still willing to work for minimum wage. Construction companies in the market today would rather hire them than a legal American kid with no experience.
things are tuff, I know... but you think you are arguing with me while you are making my point.
Shredd6 wrote:
What do you have to say to those kids Mikey? They are being denied the chance of even learning the craft of woodworking due to the abundance of illegal immigrants who have some sort of experience in an economy that is looking for cheap labor now more than ever..
again, you think keeping immigrants out will solve this problem... but it wont', so it's not of much interest to me altho, again, it makes my point.
Shredd6 wrote:Being a good woodworker and running a shop are two different things. What the owners and the workers themselves failed to realize was how easy I can organize an operation, and make it look easy. Not everyone has that skill.
so modest of you to draw the conclusion that the only possible reason they 'tanked' was that you left. Try to put your ego aside and at least be able to consider the possibility that your firing was only a sign of things to come.
Shredd6 wrote:While they did end up being descent custom woodworkers, they were never really all that organized at efficiently building $50,000 Kitchens. I was the only one who knew who was capable of doing the tasks I needed done at the time. They didn't even know themselves. I masterminded the building of the projects from beginning to end and handled the building of the most intricate aspects. I also was the one who knew who was best suited to order the products from. From the hard-ware, to the materials, parts for tools, and the wood, and who would get it there on time.
again with the modesty... I'm going to tell you a little saying that I've had to learn painfully: pride comes b4 a fall.
again, by your own admission they went out of biz... so perhaps they 'thought' they were replacing you (that's the best I can muster)... but ultimately they didn't.
Shredd6 wrote: But NONE of this happens without the enticing presence of exploiting the illegal immigrants by the owners.
again shreddy, (just want you to see how tht comes across) perhaps they HAD no choice but to do this in order to compete.
Shredd6 wrote:Mikey, it's not like I hated the people I trained or worked with. I understood that they were looking for a better life. But by no means should I ever be considered a "moron" for losing my job to illegal immigrants. In a lot of cases it's not the fault of the average American worker, but greedy unethical owners and CEOs. And occaisionally, as I mentioned before, hostage mentalities of the illegal immigrants themselves. Do you see what the very presence can create?
again, never called you a moron. get over that already. and afa greedy owners - that could be the case some of the time... but most of the time it your and my fault for buying walmart and honda while factories close left and right.
Shredd6 wrote:I do have a right to be angry at illegal immigrants for being here. They don't have the right to side-step the legal means for citizenship. And that goes for ANY illegal immigrant from any part of the world. We have a legal process, and it should be respected to uphold our sovereignty, security as a nation, and our economic stability. They don't have a legal right above US citizens to work, and yet they ignore every aspect of those laws without hesitation. I can either choose to be sympathetic or angry. Sometimes I'm a little of both. It's hard to look at a good hearted honest illegal immigrant in the eyes and tell them that you wish they would just go back to where they came from, knowing that they're just looking for a better life. But at the same time, I've seen the adverse effects of what it does to our own brothers and sisters, and I'm sorry if I care for their well being just a little bit more.
again, if all illegal immigration was stopped you would not have solved the problem.
I'd like to pass on to you a good saying that a legal immigrant told me once: 'go ahead and point your finger at someone - three fingers are pointing back at you'.