George,
I think this is a great effort.
From a songwriting standpoint, I think its too long and gets a little repetitve on the end. A lot of times when I write a song I may write 10 minutes worth of music and ussually wind up cutting it down to 4-5 minutes. Theres nothing wrong with longer songs I just think that if its going to be longer it needs to have more variations to keep a listener involved. The song doesnt seem to have what I call a middle 8 section. It
seems to just follow verse, chorus,verse,chorus,solo,verse, chorus out. A middle 8 would be a little pickup or change section maybe between the chorus leading into the solo or leading back to the vocals.
As a guitarist the rythym guitar has too much mids for my taste, I would hollow out the mids, turn the treble down slightly and maybe turn up a little amp reverb. Your lead playing is getting a lot better, but if I was playing the song on the first verse and chorus I would play the lead fill licks an octave lower, kind of mesh them with the tone of the vocals more. Then the chorus before your solo section I would go to the octave range you are playing in. I think I would cut the solo section in half. I did notice you went a little flat in the middle for a couple of barrs. Tune your ears so you can adjust on the fly quickly when that happens. I know you just recorded this live so you couldnt go back and fix it. I kinda agree with Philby, the guitar tone is a little bitey sounding to me. On my amp I would turn the master up and cut the gain and treble some, but thats just my taste, go with your gut on tone cause its your party. After the solo I would probably go back down an octave on the lead fills and then go back up an octave toward the end. Ive always thought songs should be like having sex, some kissing, foreplay, climax and then a cigarette. Try to think of your songs and solos the same way. You are telling a story and you want people to hang around til the end. You do show a lot of restraint in your solo playing. Some folks I know would just bury the whole song with lead and Im proud of the way you hold back and make room for the vocals.
For a rough cut I think its great, a little tinkering here and there and you will have a great song.
I hope I wasnt too long winded. But I like what you guys are doing, just take what I said with a grain of salt.
"A winks as good as nod to a blind man"