Now there is a can-0-worms
"W" was a mixed bag for me, strong abroad and weak at home. I generally agree with his 9/11 response. Sending radical Islamists who only want us dead into hiding in caves and spider holes for 10 years has seriously weakened their ability to wage war on the west. No serious attacks on home soil in 10 years is an outstanding accomplishment considering the fact that there are terrorists living in every major city in the US.
His economic policies were too laissiez-faire:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laissez-faire
If the goal was a free market driven by supply and demand we missed it by a mile. What we got was a supply-side rigged market where a few gamers made off with billions and the rest of us got soaked. First it was Enron and El Paso Gas (friends of "W") who gamed energy prices and were sending $10,000 utility bills to little old ladies for two years.
Next it was the Mortgage mess which Chris Dodd and Barney Frank were in up to their eyeballs as well. "W" did submit legislation to reign this in but too little, too late. That freight train was rolling full steam and required executive order to shut it down. It never happened and now here we are. Housing as an investment for everyone may never recover.
The third inaction was the speculative gaming of oil prices during his last year in office. Many of his good buddies made billions selling oil at $150 bbl while demand was falling off daily. A pure speculative bubble that poked middle class working Americans in the eye.
Each of these rigged games did tremendous damage to individual Americans, struggling businesses and our economy as a whole. By allowing them to continue unfettered did damage to our trust in government and trust in our American economic system.
Other than those issues I had no beef with Bush.