Nothing you said is wrong Cheya - I just disagreed with Jimmy's input is all, because his post was purely troll bait - nothing helpful to say, just baiting a reaction which is his style - so I bit
The "don't quit your day job" was just a there for the punch line - I mean, that's a classic punchline, no?
But I still think that while you had more "input" than Klugmo, you didn't really offer a solution - "get a producer" doesn't solve rhythem or tuning problems which are what you pointed out. If you're gonna leave the solution to common sense, then Klugmos "unlistenable" equally leaves the remedy to common sense, and ultimately you're both saying the same thing - "figure it out for yourself", except you're giving in addition some extra advice of getting a producer (which is putting the cart before the horse, right?).
I on the other hand, in no less than a sentence, did more than both of you! I stated "get an instructor" and "use a metrinome"! That at least addresses the problem of timing and tuning for our friend the op, who's profile by the way, says she is a he?
The "don't quit your day job" was just a there for the punch line - I mean, that's a classic punchline, no?
But I still think that while you had more "input" than Klugmo, you didn't really offer a solution - "get a producer" doesn't solve rhythem or tuning problems which are what you pointed out. If you're gonna leave the solution to common sense, then Klugmos "unlistenable" equally leaves the remedy to common sense, and ultimately you're both saying the same thing - "figure it out for yourself", except you're giving in addition some extra advice of getting a producer (which is putting the cart before the horse, right?).
The girl has potential, I said it.
I on the other hand, in no less than a sentence, did more than both of you! I stated "get an instructor" and "use a metrinome"! That at least addresses the problem of timing and tuning for our friend the op, who's profile by the way, says she is a he?
The more I practice, the more time I wish I had to practice
I post my band's progression / findings here::
passionfly.site/chat
temporary image gallery: passionfly.smugmug dotcom
Join us, give us feedback - talk music, talk UFO's, just don't talk politics and no one will get hurt! haha.
I post my band's progression / findings here::
passionfly.site/chat
temporary image gallery: passionfly.smugmug dotcom
Join us, give us feedback - talk music, talk UFO's, just don't talk politics and no one will get hurt! haha.




