Bands And Albums.

In terms of overrated, I'd have to put in my vote for Matthew Bellamy, from Muse.

Amen sir...Frankie Boyle summed up Muse on Buzzcocks the other week "Thats the first time I heard Muse & knowing how big they are they're surprisingly rubbish, like not good at all"...or summin along them lines. Pretty much exactly what I thought first time I heard 'em.

Threads like this kinda depress me tbh. I'm not a Nirvana fan but I think Cobain was way more interesting & inventive that 99% of the technically correct guitarists that are praised on forums like this. There is no right or wrong way to play an instrument. However people seem happy to ape other players, endlessly trying to copy their sound. Where's the creativity in that ?

The Edge does suck tho...

I happen to think Cobain is the most overated musician ever. Hell the drummer proved to be better lets be honest.

I believe to be overrated you have to first be rated high. No one ever said Cobain was a great guitarist, but he was very effective at what he did and a great song writer. Grohl's songs are OK but nowhere near the depth of Nirvana songs. A lot of metal people don't like him because he pretty much ended the 80's hair metal crap.

I'd go with Cobain....Grohl was the only real talent in that band. Not a big fan of George Lynch either.

Janick Gers. He is a good musician but bad guitarist.

As far as technical skills go, I'd say Kirk Hammett is pretty overrated. Classic guitarist, but I think he stopped trying in the late 80's.

Keith Richards
Neil Young
Malcolm Young
Eric Clapton

Didn't go into the why's and wherefores...

I have to go with The Edge myself. Anybody can sound cool with the amount of effects he uses, but I saw bits of him playing without all of it on a documentary. I was not impressed. Take it all away, he doesn't have much.
Pretty much by his own admission he spends hours, if not days tweaking all his racks. Time better spent playing, in my opinion.

i'll go w slash.

i just NEVER got wtf was the big deal about this guy. all hat and no cattle (or talent)....well, i mean he can play pentatonic blue box licks w some skill and it's not like he's a bad gtrst....i just don't know why so many think he's this great gtrst.

same for AXL Rose being a great singer! mah gawd, that guy couldn't swing if he was hanging from a rope! complete and total lack of soul.

Yeah but Slash wears cool hats. That has to count for something.

I believe to be overrated you have to first be rated high. No one ever said Cobain was a great guitarist, but he was very effective at what he did and a great song writer. Grohl's songs are OK but nowhere near the depth of Nirvana songs. A lot of metal people don't like him because he pretty much ended the 80's hair metal crap.

I was thinking the same thing reading the first page.

I disagree with a few guitarists listed, especially slash.. I've learned EHV solos like Hot for teacher, eruption, etc.. which are technically difficult and require the ability to mimic the expressions correctly. I recently learned the end solo to "sweet child" and found the expressions, and one of the runs to be equally as difficult. The dude might not have many flavors, but he's got some really good raw talent and phrasings to say the least.

Neil young.. well yeah, I don't think he's so hot on leads, but I don't remember many people bringing him up in the same contexts as Jimmy Page, EVH, yngwie..

Keith Richards.. well that dude is something of an oddity. Never a great soloist, but his phrasing is excellent and he has mixed a huge variety of styles into his playing over the years. What makes him so great is his intricate melodies and rhythm playing- it's really spectacular when you take a listen to the parts of the song outside the solos.

with malcolm young, I don't think anyone ever accused him of being a great guitarist, but the reality is that he's one of the strongest rhythm guitarists in his genre. He's never been complex or versatile, but the dude can rock a rhythm better than most bass players IMO.

I think my vote for over-rated goes to a TIE:

Mark Tremonti (Creed)
It seems like everyone I've met in the last 5 years just raves about how this guy is a guitar god.. I just don't see it. He's sloppy, his phrasing sucks, and he doesn't really seem to be actually picking individual notes when shredding as much as just using 12x as much distortion as needed and flailing his fingers as fast as he can. It looks like what I did my first year playing when I was pretending to shred, but really had no idea what a scale was, or the skill to pull it off.

The Edge
I never understood why anyone fawned over the guy, all he really seemed to do was set his delay precisely to the timing of the songs and increase the feedback to carry several measures.. not exactly exceptional .. hell, david gilmour was doing that 5 years earlier.


Speaking of Gilmour.. in a opposite topic, I'd say he's one of the most under-rated guitarists out there.

SLASH

Gotta love the ratings...Rolling Stone, etc, hilarious...

Kurt Cobain







.