Yeah, Prevost82.
It's good to play with others for that very reason. Some musicians are overconfident (and I never want to be one of them).
That's a bit of a unusual statement .... because I only play with very confident players with player that can get the job done (no egos, rehearsed and ready to go, being able to critic his work, etc). I want to know that if I put off a syncopation rhythm and pull the beat with it, that the drums and bass will be holding the one beat so when I come out of it they are there and not get pulled of the beat and confident player s know how to drive a groove and make it huge.
Most of the stuff I do has no band rehearsals ... we learn the material on our own and go play a show and it comes off with a deep groove and tight changes and sounds like the band has been together for years ... but you need the right people to pull this off. They are pro players, have their EARS ON (intensely listening to everyone in the band, driving the groove and playing out of box) and also be playing in a HEADS UP (looking for queues)
We always get asked ... "wow what a tight band ... how long have you been playing together" ... me "aah ... one set"
I was in the studio (I was the MD for this project) this past weekend laying down 12 original songs for a artist. I put together the 3pc rhythm section for this project all pro players.
We got setup around 7pm on friday night and I started playing some stuff off the cuff and calling out the cord changes and movements as we went though the song ... it went from fusion jazz to Prog rock to a ballet and back to fusion. I usually do this sort of thing with new players to see how quick the musicians can feel the changes coming, how well they execute the changes and how well they can play out of the box.
The bass player and I have been playing together for 3 yrs and we communicate, musically very well (it's uncanny how well he reads where I'm going next, when most of the time I don't even know). The drummer jumped into the song with both feet, hit every change as tight as a nuns c**t and could play so far out of the box it made my head spin, in the fusion section he moved the 1 beat over to the "and" beat, as the bass player and I held the 1 beat, then the drummer came back to the 1 off a fill, that in my book is way cool. The drummer fit in as if we've play together for years, excellent musical communication and a driving groove and that set the stage for the weekend.
None of us had rehearsed the songs because they was no recordings to practice to. We had 4 hrs of pre-production (engineer setting us up for recording) on friday night where we ran through the material and I did some minor arranging changes to songs and we went through the intro, out-tro's, heads, turn arounds and meter of the songs.
Saturday we started tracking around 2pm. Of the 12 songs, 8 were done with a click track, we'd rehearsed the song once, then recorded the song 3 times. Four of the songs we couldn't be record with a click because of the syncopation and intentional meter changes and these had to be recorded right though with no mistakes. The overall majority of the songs, the 2nd take was the best ... for drive of the groove, dynamics and creativity. We were done recording the 12 songs in 8 hrs (rhythm section only) the guitar and vox will be tracked by the artist this week and it's going to be a smoking CD. The raw tracks sounded great ... very tight and clean. The artist was happy with the raw tracks, the sound engineer could believe we got though all the songs so fast and the rhythm section (bass drums and me on Hammond) had a blast playing with each other.
We were way out of the comfort zone all weekend and that is where good music is made IMHO