#24611 by
Craig Maxim
Thu Mar 06, 2008 8:26 pm
Well,
You guys gotta consider that this is coming off a whole thread pretty much about screamer bands.
I think it is a passing fad, like disco was. That's just personal opinion, and only time will tell.
I try to give honest feedback, whether it is my favorite genre or not, and when I do, I try to be objective about it. Being in the biz, I come across alot of screamer bands, and compete with them all the time in Battle of the Bands across Atlanta. So I think I have good first hand exposure on a regular basis to that field. btw... no screamer band has EVER beat us at a battle. Their own fans end up cheering more for us than the bands they came to see.
One thing I mentioned in other posts, is that some industry sources of mine, have confided that screamer music is on the way out. This may take a few years, who knows? But I share that info, not as an insult, but as helpful knowledge, that exclusively screamer bands may want to branch out a little, so when and if, the hammer does fall, you are somewhat protected and can adapt to the change.
Back in the day, metal heads had no problem saying and spray painting "Disco Sucks!" all over the place. Had you guys been my age back then, you would have been among the backlash almost certainly.
Consider Panic At The Disco's new album. They are from an Emo oriented background, but their new album is said to be Classic Rock oriented. They were inspired after getting into the Beatles and The Stones and others, and said something along the lines of...
"Emo was ok, when we were kids. We wrote most of that album when we were 17. But now we are 21 and growing up, and we realize that not everything is gloomy, all relationships are not bad. People don't always want to be depressed. This album is for coming home after work, and pumping you up a little."
PATD is Emo, not screaming, but like screaming, Emo is a fad. People grow out of it. The hair metal bands of the 80's had their day, Disco had it's day. Emo is having it's day and so is screamer rock.
But it's all an attempt to stretch boundaries and find something new. When the new gets old, another "new" comes along. Every generation has it's new thing, and every generation switches when the newer "new" thing comes along.
Jazz has not disappeared. R&B has not disappeared. Screaming is limited in it's versatility, whereas genres like the one's mentioned, can evolve and go many more places. There are only so many ways to scream. And while the supporting music can change underneath, the focal point is still going to be the lead vocalist. After awhile, it has nowhere to go creatively.
Hey, I actually like some Disco still, and some disco songs have survived by being re-mixed into hip hop or rave, etc... But no one is going to build a career on disco any longer. And some very talented people, lost their careers for good, when the backlash against disco took hold, because they were pigeon holed as a "disco singer" and even when they tried to change, it was too late. Their careers were over.
I mention these things, to help you avoid falling into the same fate. I'm looking out for you guys, not trying to demean you.