Your opinion is also a valid one, but not as true as you'd think. If there is one thing I've learned over all those years it's this: The cream really does rise to the top. No matter where you are, if you can create a scene, produce an audience who likes your music, then there are other audiences who will also. Then you will know who you need to know because they are looking for you.
Well, there's cream...and then there is Cream... (Pun intended) But seriously, I can count
on one hand (maybe two) post -mordern musicians who actually changed the face of popular music, while doing all that you described to produce audiences. All the rest were just good worker -bees or failures. I can show you a million "success-stories ' if success means a Waylon Jennings bus-ride... (Who, btw, while I do respect his efforts, he simply didn't make the Post-Modern Top-ten of the universe in my book...)
No matter how it might seem, there really aren't that many great songs, songwriters, singers, guitarists, bands, etc...out there who are diligent about rising above the noise. Of those who are, a very high percentage will do so if they simply work to get better every day and don't give up. The only time you have no chance is when you quit. It does take time to establish a network of venues so it become a matter of whether you can keep a band together long enough to get there. That's why I'm solo.
Keep in mind that the noise was much less...back when Rock n Roll started out... Now, its impossible to
not get buried in noise. I Believe the reason we have no new top-ten post-modern music heros of the universe emerging , has more to do with lowest -common-denominator tastes and preferences of marketers who realized nobody gets rich off the "gold". To put it another way, Gold is NOT being promoted, hence the industry is futile for real cutting edge artists.
Once you have "the goods" people will know it. When I said about it has little to do with talent, what I mean is that there are lots of talented people who decided they didn't really want this lifestyle after all. It isn't for everyone. Waylon Jennings has one of my favorite quotes, "Making it big is just a glorified bus ride" and that is where most talented people who could be huge stars someday will get off the merry-go-round.
Partially agree... First, can you tell me what you mean by "goods'...? (According to some...Bieber has the goods...).. 2nd, even if God , himself showed up at A Fillmore stage revival, with a solid platinum Strat, there will be some jack-ass that will expect him to play for free... (in a manner of speaking) . If God were to decline the request, he'd suddenly be optioned right in there with Siegfried and Roy as a freak-show, instead of the next Beatles or whatever... My whole point is that having the goods, may not be the actual ticket anymore, since its
not the Gold that's being promoted.
I'm not trying to be arrogant when I say that most of you would last about 2 or 3 months tops touring like a successful band has to. It's not easy being away from your family and stressing out over how much you need to get to the next town. It's not easy dealing with different people and places everyday. Some people thrive on it (like me!), but most get disillusioned when they find out that they are migratory homeless people. Yes, you could tour less and be happy at home more, but then you aren't paying the bills.
That's the trade off.
Actually you give me far too much credit..

In My present condition, I wouldn't last 7 days...
But if its any consolation, the worlds biggest, baddest band, ever, in the history of rock,'roll didn't survive the touring either, and they gave it up (Flat out quit) to make concept albums instead.
As for endurance, I agree and recognize how grueling the work part is... Can you imagine, a tour schedule AND the responsibility to work up one hit after hit for these bands?
People wonder why Britney Spears blew a gasket...(And she wasn't even the writer for the songs she did)
To succeed logistically in this business, you MUST:
1) NOT be tied down.
2) BE physically Healthy
3) Willing to bleed for the cause
4) Function without sleep
5) Maintain full charm throughout the day...