Is he gone?
I missed all this, but my band doesnt play with a setlist. We may start with one and then the crowd starts yelling for thier favorites and we just go with the flow. I love improv, Ive done open mics at times and have a couple of friends who do solo gigs and ask me to play with them. Its a lot of fun. My band improvs sections of songs at times its a lot of fun.
I would be curious like others one here to hear how many gigs this guy has done. Things change real quick when you start moving equipment and try to keep other bandmembers inspired to play.
It seems to me that thru the years the people that claimed to like improv as a form really didnt take the time to learn any structure to their music to start with.
But hey if something is working for you and your having fun with it then go for it.
I think Phish and groups of that nature are an acquired taste. I listen some and listen on my XM radio to a station that has these groups. But they are very good ussually what I heard. I cant imagine just getting with 3-7 people and being able to create music that would make people want to keep coming back and seeing you over and over. I think there has to be a history of playing together for a long period of time to get to the level that you could keep people interested. And in that history the musicians would have to have started with some common songs and structures to do what they do. This goes for the Grateful Dead or any jam band, at some point they did their homework. If you look historically at these groups they either spent a lot of time together or came together from more structured bands.
Im in agreement with Bob about the sad state of the music economy these days. Its tough when it comes to getting paid, and after doing around 1000 gigs or more there is a point to where you want to do more than just get in front of people and jam. Our audience for my band, they come and want to hear the same songs over and over again.
As I always say there are no real rules to this game. So good luck to whatever it is you want out of music.
I missed all this, but my band doesnt play with a setlist. We may start with one and then the crowd starts yelling for thier favorites and we just go with the flow. I love improv, Ive done open mics at times and have a couple of friends who do solo gigs and ask me to play with them. Its a lot of fun. My band improvs sections of songs at times its a lot of fun.
I would be curious like others one here to hear how many gigs this guy has done. Things change real quick when you start moving equipment and try to keep other bandmembers inspired to play.
It seems to me that thru the years the people that claimed to like improv as a form really didnt take the time to learn any structure to their music to start with.
But hey if something is working for you and your having fun with it then go for it.
I think Phish and groups of that nature are an acquired taste. I listen some and listen on my XM radio to a station that has these groups. But they are very good ussually what I heard. I cant imagine just getting with 3-7 people and being able to create music that would make people want to keep coming back and seeing you over and over. I think there has to be a history of playing together for a long period of time to get to the level that you could keep people interested. And in that history the musicians would have to have started with some common songs and structures to do what they do. This goes for the Grateful Dead or any jam band, at some point they did their homework. If you look historically at these groups they either spent a lot of time together or came together from more structured bands.
Im in agreement with Bob about the sad state of the music economy these days. Its tough when it comes to getting paid, and after doing around 1000 gigs or more there is a point to where you want to do more than just get in front of people and jam. Our audience for my band, they come and want to hear the same songs over and over again.
As I always say there are no real rules to this game. So good luck to whatever it is you want out of music.
"A winks as good as nod to a blind man"




