Hayden King wrote:
first off I believe that Phil has the same opinion on America as me: this country is great... our leaders are scum o the earth!
No disagreement there.
Hayden King wrote:
This country has been ruled by manipulation and propaganda for at least 5 decades.
Longer.
But so are
all governments.
Hayden King wrote:
The Shaw was inserted by and a pawn of the US government (C.I.A./C.F.R.) just as Hussein/Noriega.
This was a little different. The two you mentioned, were common thugs, that America had a working relationship with... until their usefulness expired. The Shah was royalty. His father had ruled before him, but was exiled by Britain and the Soviet Union, who invaded Iran, after the King (The Shah's Father) refused to allow his Trans-Iranian Railway to be used to bring military supplies through Iran, in support of the war effort against Germany. Britain and The Soviet Union were allies, of course.
The Father, however, was a reformer and progressive thinker, just as his son was. And the son, was really, merely continuing the modernization efforts the father had already begun, during his reign.
In any event, one year after the Father was exiled, America became involved in the war, and now ALL THREE COUNTRIES (Britain, Soviet Union, America) had troops in Iran, and were in effect, running the country, in order to ensure the protection of the trains, and supply route, as well, as the foreign investments in the oil fields, to keep the oil flowing too.
After America became involved, the son... Mohammad Reza Pahlavi (Shah of Iran) was "allowed" to accede to the throne, to replace his father as King of Iran. At the behest of the Clerics, who did not like the Modernization going on, the freedoms granted women, etc... political unrest grew, and a new Prime Minister was named by the Iranian Parliament, who promptly nationalized all Oil Production in Iran. After several attempts on his life, by a Communistic Political Party in Iran, and his political enemy being named Prime Minister... he fled Iran.
Wanting their interests restored, America and the UK, then staged a coup, to return the King (The Shah) back to power.
For his part... the Shah, was only wanting to continue the reforms and modernization, his father had begun. As Shah, this meant, he elevated women's rights, so that they could even be lawyers and judges in Iran. He sought to wipe out illiteracy in his country, through a massive public education system. And illiteracy has ALWAYS been a problem in Muslim nations. They are among the most illiterate in the world. Not "under-educated".... ILLITERATE! And he modernized his country and brought it prosperity.
Under the Shah's rule, in only two decades, Iran became the strongest militarily, and the wealthiest country in the Middle East. An amazing accomplishment.
He was not a "puppet" in the traditional sense. His family was a ruling royal DYNASTY, and he received support from America and Britain, because with him, the oil continued to flow. He opposed nationalizing the oil production, because he anticipated an oil embargo by the west, if this occurred, which could them ruin Iran economically, and halt the modernization and reforms he was working toward.
His vision was COOPERATION with America and others, and he saw his country becoming one of 5 major world governments. He personally opposed Communism, and so preferred working with America, on his country's modernization, to the Soviet Union.
But the same religious zealots, the powerful Clerics, who first opposed his father, and for the same reasons, then went after the son.
The rest is history.
But The Shah was not so much a "puppet" - As a "pragmatist".
But his INTENTIONS were HONORABLE and TRUE.
Do you disagree with that as well?
Hayden King wrote:
pretty much everything we hear through the corporate media (state TV) is rhetoric and propaganda based; nearly every news source in the US TV/radio/newspaper is owned by one of 5 corporations. The major publishers here are owned by them as well.
Ok... there are 5 Mega-Companies that control most of our media. Am I getting that right?
Ultimately, what does that mean to us?
It seems ominous and manipulative, and in some ways it is. But how much so? Not as much as some would like to believe. Just consider how many political parties in America really have any chance of holding power....
Gee... TWO.
Is that of less concern, than that the media is controlled by
FIVE companies? And of the five companies, who are they "ALL" in the tank for? Democrats? Or... Republicans? They certainly fight it out, among the two choices, with Radio and FoxNews more in the Conservative camp, and CNN, MsNBC, Network News, etc... in the tank for Liberals.
We agree, that there is deception. That handfuls of powerful families in the world, pull strings among COUNTRIES and NATIONS worldwide. That we are being duped, and manipulated, and CONDITIONED to accept their will for our lives.
AGREED! But they aren't as
united, or as
all-powerful, as you believe.
There is
REAL dissension among various factions, and not just media-created dissension to keep up appearances. And they are not all ruthless, evil, people. Many, likely believe, they are building a civil world, for the benefit of all. Remember... they also have families, that have to live with what they create, as well as having their descendents for many generations, having to live with the results as well.
Hayden King wrote:
I believe Phil loves this country just as much as you and I, but is ready to see heads roll for the bullshit that they put us through and feed us!
Maybe he does, maybe he doesn't.
But killing the baby to save it, is never a good strategy.
His attitudes are POISONOUS, and not liberating, revolutionary, or BENEFICIAL. All they can do, is DESTROY. To rebuild something which has fallen, broken or gotten off track... you need to first REVIVE and RECAPTURE, it's past sense of VALUE... not DEGRADE THAT VALUE!
You can call for Revolution, or Revival, or Renewal, but it must be done in a POSITIVE CONTEXT, not a DEATHLY NEGATIVE one. No one wants to save something that is irredeemably rotten! Things that are completely rotten, are only worth TRASHING!
And as Iranians have now discovered... the replacement, may very well be
FAR WORSE, than the original problem! And that replacement may take DECADES or even CENTURIES, to remove, and give the next thing a chance.
PRIDE IN AMERICAN VALUES AND IDEALS is what will help restore this country, and more than RESTORE IT, but enable it to live up to it's
ORIGINAL IDEALS!