Andragon wrote:Knockin' on Heaven's Door should have been left a folk song and that's that.
Simple Man is a great song. Both versions are excellent.
Hmmm... there are so many official covers that sucked. Most of the ones that were on the MetallicA tribute album sucked.
Three Days Grace covered Chris Isaak's Wicked Game in their own style, which I like. It was really good, imo.
Johnny Cash should stop ruining great songs like Hurt and Rusty Cage. Poor Soundgarden.
andy, Johnny Cash's version of hurt actually conveys the emotions of hurt, pain, regret, sorrow...what trent reznor did was write a song for the market that he knew would eat it up, have you seen where he came from? look it up on youtube, trent reznor in the 80's I wanna say, just another 80's dude who was playing with synth's and some how he made a career outta it.
as for Mariyln Manson covers, you have to like what he's doing in the first place, but if you didn't like the original genre of "Sweet Dreams" and you hear the cover you might like it, at least my grumpy dad did haha. What I really like is when a rock band (70's prog especially) takes a stab at some classical music, but that's not a cover, that's an interpretation so it's different