Musician Forum - Band Discussion Board - BandMix

I would not be able to choose. Both versions have their merits.

There isn't much I like about Metallica

Actually they're both covers of a traditional Irish song. I like Thin Lizzy but it's just a preference.

Thin Lizzy...Did'nt care for Metallica's version at all. Was the beginning of the end as far as I'm concerned...

Enterro-Fox wrote:I want to ask what you prefer...

Whiskey In the Jar by Thin Lizzy,or the cover by Metallica

E.Fox,
Neither one, as I much prefer the Tommy Makem & Roger McGuinn version from Mcguinn's "Treasures From The Folk Den " album. Its a classic song and You-Tube abounds with superior versions.

However, I have been listening to Metalica's version more often of late because I have it loaded on one of my cassette tapes that I listen to back at my work site. I love the tune and have become more tolerant of the Metallica version. Another song that Metallica covered OK , but not nearly as good as the original, is Blue Oyster Cult's " Astronomy" .

As for Thin Lizzy, I recall jammin' out on "Boys Are Back In Town" many times back in the day. THAT'S a great song to cover!

It's all a mater of opinion, of course.
Howlin'

Hey, Howlin, what bout their song Emerald?