Musician Forum - Band Discussion Board - BandMix

check out my stuff and let me know

Nah....

Singing usually involves a melodic progression, maybe your definition of singing doesn't include melody. Making noise isn't singing IMO. I don't usually offer negative criticism of anybody but I think you need to re-think your definition of singing. Sorry...

Well, the recordings are pretty bad quality. Nice influences, but you should record at least one clean recording and put it up for others to see. I cannot tell if you sound bad or it's just the recording, to be hoenst.

Good god, I mean I detest screamo and hardcore, but this is beyond.

The first track isn't bad, if you exclude the fact that no one is in time. (ugghhh)

And the fact that as soon as you start screaming it's truly awful.

If you and the boys lose the screamo/hardcore vocals and play it all together in time, correct notes, it sounds encouraging and possibly worth a re-record.

Oh my! Ok guys pull it down try it again. I know my timing aint all that. But I dont think I could play that far out if I wantd to.

Dont be discouraged, just roll it up again, a little tighter.

Try banking, or Police work, or teaching.... or anything other than music. I am sorry but I find nothing to even build from. The term train wreck was mentioned. That term sums it up. Really I am sorry, but you need to be realistic.

Actually you might be on to a new genre: atonal death rock. Later....

fisherman bob wrote:Actually you might be on to a new genre: atonal death rock. Later....

Thats funny Bob, The name TRAIN RECK could be a band name. I realy dont want to bash annyone, But that is bad, keep trying guys. peace

i like track 1-- just based on that (and no offense, but i could be wrong) i think you have a good sounding voice.

so, why destroy it with something like track 2? dont growl the part that goes "dont come near me or i will beat you". why not just sing/yell that?

these 2 tracks remind me of Stabbing Westward. i see some value in them, although yea, they do need work.

Im with Crip I'll pass for now..........................................



Years ago I played with a guy named Coburn Pharr (singer). I couldnt stand his singing and finally fired him.

A couple of years later he was the singer for a band called Annilator and toured the world backing up Judas Priest. I finally broke down and bought the album he was on. Same vocals I had on some homegrown tapes, but it fit the bands sound.

So Im not going to critisize anyones style of music, but as I said I'll pass on jamming for now

Good Luck and dont let us discourage you from pursuing your passion!

You know, any of you "musicians" that tell people to get another job etc must really have a big ego. Tolerance is not just a machinists' term, jerk off..

Especially when not everyone thinks YOUR sheet is any good either. Did you spring from the womb a superstar? I don't think so..

Fact is not everyone likes everything, but when you go that far you are talking out of your ass.

For some it's par for the course, for others try to think before you sheet on someone you don't even know.

For the record, I have heard far worse ....

No pro critics here, lemme promise you that.. Ignore the dicks, aka ssdd.

Constructive criticism is one thing, some jackass no one ever heard of taking that to the limit near the holidays is just more bullshit no one wants to hear. Grow a set or just grow up, you know who you are and no one thinks much of you either. If they did, you might be gainfully employed and no, not at the gas station as a Petroleum Engineer etc.

Scott, this is by far your smartest post. I'm impressed lol
But you should read that to yourself at least once before you post a childish comment in threads.