Musician Forum - Band Discussion Board - BandMix

Hi,

I'm young minimalist composier and I'll be happy if you could tell me what do you think about my music?

This very important for me.

There is my music myspace:
http://www.myspace.com/554406411

Thanks for help!

2 things:

1) you spelled composer wrong

2) does "young minimalist composier" mean you're a partial nudist?

Nice job Maciej. It's not minimalist like Glass and it's not too "new agey". Best of luck.

My advise is to find an way to judge your own music without going to the web.
You're never going to get honest answers here.

Most people that look for feedback here are just looking for praise...

and it's not real.......

Put it up on your BandMix page and I'll be glad to tell you what I think.

In Nuitee you hang onto the same phrase too long, although it’s a pleasant phrase. It’s very short, more an idea than a full fleshed out tune. The beginning has good tones to it. I was disappointed when you outright dropped the xylophone sound at 0:31 just to fade it in later. In my opinion it was too much change for that transition.

“Autumn Night” It’s a nice melody and anyone will get the gist, but it needs more variation than the three chords. Don’t get me wrong it has some nice crescendos and overall is very pleasant sounding. Really well played, but the same three chords for four minutes will get old no matter how masterfully done. The single notes are nice in the beginning. When you play them harder near the end, it should be full chords not single notes. It’s an increase in energy you’re trying to obviously convey and single notes just won’t do that no matter how hard you hit the key. It’s a great idea, in my opinion it just needs more variation.

I have received some great thoughtful critiques here and if you ask for an honest opinion, you will eventually get it whether you like it or not. The trick is to remember it is just that. One person's opinion.

nice work but it needs to have more (imo) like maybe some strings or something

WRONG Stranger.

Really now.....? The kid has one post, knows no one here. And you think he's really looking for useful criticism?

He's looking for someone to say.."Wow...you're great. It's some of the best music I've ever heard...you're going to be famous...."

If it was someone who'd contributed to the community for a while and then wanted some feedback that's one thing...

But these one post wonders......

And take the Damn bold button off...what are you yelling all the time?

Stranger,
I have been on this site since oct.
I introduced myself and if you visited my profile it would say wrote about 10-15 good song.

Stranger,sorry the post went without me finishing.
I wanted to say that some one suggested I put some of it out there.
I did and I did ask for feed back.
Now that you mentioned it I guess I did look for a little flattery.
When you only play by yourself you are your worst critic.

I won't post anything if I hate your music. But if it has any redeeming qualities at all I will give some encouraging words or advice.

jimmydanger wrote:I won't post anything if I hate your music. But if it has any redeeming qualities at all I will give some encouraging words or advice.

You did for me once and I thank you for that you gave excellent feedback.

Sorry to be harsh but any artist has to be there own critic. Otherwise you write for others and not your own muse.

And I get really tired of all these people posting "What do you think of my song?" posts...They're just so lame......

Stranger wrote:Sorry to be harsh but any artist has to be there own critic. Otherwise you write for others and not your own muse.

And I get really tired of all these people posting "What do you think of my song?" posts...They're just so lame......

You get the last word stranger.
good luck