Musician Forum - Band Discussion Board - BandMix

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAV0XrbE ... verified=1

I like this!

I'd like to hear some comments on this one.

It hits my ear almost like a Motown thing, yet the content is rather incongruous. It's like it's at odds with the genre. The basic idea works, yet the use of more...hop-hoppish?...language either ruins it, or makes it.

Is this a work of comedy? A mere novelty song? Or can it stand as an actual song? I think it's certainly catchy enough.

It has the classic structure of the 60's soul hit, save the rather abrupt ending. I think it should have either faded out, or come 'round full circle to the simple piano intro.

Your thoughts?

Er ah ... anything that starts off saying FU ain't fit for consumption.

sanshouheil wrote:Er ah ... anything that starts off saying FU ain't fit for consumption.

This from a guy who starts off so many posts with "WTF."

Not picking on you, sans. I'm just saying that the language of the average American has become rather used to the F-bomb, &, whether or not you're willing to admit it, that includes you, sans, with your not-so-innocent allusion to it, so frequently.

That being said, I still contend that this is a pretty cool song. It shows the lyricist's frustration in a common, everyday way, & yet still manages to sound like a happy, friendly tune.

Is this what you can see for the future of pop?

Cee Lo Green has had one helluva lotta hits on this song, & I'll bet that there are a lot of ppl that'll be singing along...

I take no offense to your statements Phil.
I am well aware I have a foul mouth. Not something I am proud of as I consider it poor communications and it gets me into trouble on a regular basis.
Makes it all the more offensive to me being one of my own shortcomings as a man.
Thus I condemn and avoid as much as my limited will allows.

The average American is not worth the bullet it would take to be rid of them.
No honor, no morality.
Very easy to recognize that with which we personally struggle.

But...but...morality issues aside - what about the damned song?

I had a listen and I'll get out the way, song structure and all, very well done and obviously from England because they looooove that sound. And hubs and I were cracking up because sometimes there's nothing you can say but FU sometimes and I've said this a lot when people piss me off. A well placed FU can be quite therapeutic and it soothes the soul.

Sans, don't you remember Marianne Faithfull's "Why'd Ya Do It?"

I knew right away he was industry. It smells like industry (industry is those songs you hear when you go to pitch your material to the A&R guy and he in turn has to play a project he's working on -- usually impeccable songwriting structure, weak lyrics and otherwise just lame), and my suspicions were confirmed when I recognized the voice as the guy from Gnarls Barkley. Well, they got away with "Crazy" and this song is a hell of a lot better.

My two pennies.

Chaeya

I like the funny stuff, as you all know, & I don't get all offended at adult content.

I mean, look at Red Peters - big productions, well-written & -performed pieces of music. Here's some, & again - warning! adult content:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VmJvvo8PvIg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNCVriK5PjI

Or Frank Zappa, the master -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oL_DxT2UOyo

The music is still good, on each & every one of them, & if you alter the lyric to make it radio-friendly (like Cee Lo is doing with that song, calling it "Forget You"), it takes some of the sting away.

Oh snap, I forgot about Frank! How could I do that?!

I don't mind it either, sometimes it's hilarious.

Chaeya

PHIL!!!!! HA HA LMAO!!! So I'm riding in my car and my daughter who loves KITSCH FM has it on and what do I hear? FU but it's "Forget You" on the radio. The bastard!

"Crazy" was Gnarls Barkley's first hit. Danger Mouse is a producer from New York and Cee Loo is a rapper from Atlanta. Danger Mouse produced the Gorillaz Demon Day's release. They were smart, they went to England and got signed. They definitely hooked up with the right person.

Chaeya

To all the bitchers and whiners:

"Want to lose 10 lbs of ugly fat? Cut off your head and throw your dashiki in the trash".

Hey! Leave my daishiki outta this!

philbymon wrote:
I like this!

I can't pull this up on me phone.
It errors out when I try to play it.

Maxim, can you fix it?

huh...my wife got it on hers...

Now tell me, someone - does this not remind you of "(I Know) I'm Losing You" which was done by the Supremes, Rod Stewart, Rare Earth, The Temptations, & Vanilla Fudge, among others? Except this one's in a major key, where Losing You was in a minor one...

sanshouheil wrote:Er ah ... anything that starts off saying FU ain't fit for consumption.

what about "Kick out the jams, mutherfucker!"?