i mean I can play as fast as anyone I know and to some extent I can shredd like hell, but give me the emotion.
BINGO!
I'll take something with FEELING any time. I can play fast, and JW will probably confirm that, but I go for feel every time. I paid a lot of attention to something I read in an article a while back. Stevie Ray Vaughn played in a blues festival with BB King and wanted to sit in so BB said ok. Vaughn told him he'd need a couple of minutes to get warmed up, so BB turned him loose and he played every lick he could think of, jamming his butt off.
Then BB King took over...and blew Vaughn right off the stage...
Vaughn knew it and asked him later, how did you do that? ONE NOTE and you blew me right out of the water...ONE NOTE...
BB told him "put everything you got into every note." Every ounce of soul you have into every note you play, that's what makes Clapton great, BB King, David Gilmour, Jimmy Page, Duanne Allman, Billy Gibbons and so on. Gibbons can drag enough soul to fill a Mac truck out of one note.
Who cares if you can play 138 notes in 4 seconds if not one of them actually SAYS anything?
I've never practiced a scale in my life, except on sax in high school...hated every minute of it. Took music theory too, forgot all of it before the next year was over. When I practiced, I would work on my parts for a few minutes then doodle on jazz solo style stuff for twice as long. Then back to work on the actual parts.
Band director walked by the practice room one day and heard me, looked in the small window to see who it was, I thought 'oh crap, I'm busted'...he walked in, asked me if I could do the same in another key. (I was doodling in D on a baritone sax, he wanted concert Bflat, or G on the bari). I tried it, he told me to take the solo in a specific song that Friday night at a concert when trombone usually did it. From then on I was playing baritone sax solos in the jazz band...
Did scales help? Or theory? Nope...being able to hear something in my head and make the horn do it was all that ever helped, same on guitar. Right now I would have to sit there and peck my way through any scales, I don't know them and don't care to. I play what goes through my head, I'm actually best under pressure and ad libbing it, and I try to - probably not very successfully - put all the soul I can into every note. The only thing scales did was train my fingers to know where the notes were. Could have done that doodling just as well...
As far as actual practice goes, I'm horrible at it. I mostly just doodle, see what interesting licks come out. When I have to learn specific songs, then I do work on them, but usually any other time I just doodle around, play through songs I've written or am in the process of working up, play old songs or parts of them I've known for 30 years...anything but scales...
Oh, almost always on acoustic, I rarely practice on an electric at all. Working to find the notes on an acoustic will make it almost effortless when you switch to electric, and when I practice electric it's almost always clean, no effects. But you do have to get accustomed to the different neck for a few minutes, so if you're about to go onstage, always warm up on an electric, the one you intend to use, just before going onstage. You don't want to start off the night fumbling around trying to get accustomed to a different guitar neck...been there, done that...it ain't pretty...
I'm a member of the BOMB SQUAD.
If you see me running, better catch up!
http://billy-griffis-jr.artistwebsites.com/